Questions / Quant research, Research decisions

Choose the success metric first

Foundation, about 6 minutes. Question R038.

A model has no real effect. You test 20 independent metrics at 5% each. What is the probability that at least one looks significant?

Answer it in the app It's free. You get hints, a second try if you miss, and a follow-up question.

Show the answer and worked solution

Answer: 0.6415 probability

  1. Each metric stays non-significant with probability 0.95.
  2. All 20 stay quiet with probability 0.95²⁰ ≈ 0.358.
  3. At least one false positive: 1 − 0.358 ≈ 0.642.

Interview shortcut. At least one of 20: 1 − 0.95²⁰ ≈ 64%.

Takeaway. Reporting the best of many metrics rewards noise.

In the app this has a follow-up where one thing about the setup changes. Try the follow-up.

More research decisions questions